← All articles

Virtual assistant vs PA: cost, cover and control compared

For most small businesses, a virtual assistant is the cheaper and more flexible choice, because you pay a monthly fee instead of a salary plus employer costs. An in-house PA is worth the extra money when the job needs someone physically there, all day, every day.

Virtual assistant or in-house PA?

For most small businesses, a virtual assistant is the cheaper and more flexible choice, because you pay a monthly fee instead of a salary plus employer costs. An in-house PA is worth the extra money when the job needs someone physically there, all day, every day.

What's the real difference between a virtual assistant and a PA?

Less than the job titles suggest. Both look after your inbox, your diary, your travel and the steady drizzle of small jobs that stops you doing the work you're actually paid for. The differences that matter are where the person sits and who employs them.

An in-house PA is your employee, at a desk in your office, on your payroll. A virtual assistant works remotely, and if you come through an agency you're buying a service rather than taking on a member of staff. "Virtual assistant" also covers a wide range, from a lone freelancer to a managed team, and those options behave quite differently.

Most remote PA vs in-house decisions come down to three things, so I'll take them in turn.

What does each option really cost?

Our personal assistant service is £1,000 per month with no setup fees. That's £12,000 a year.

An in-house PA starts with a salary , and the salary is only the part you see in the advert. As the employer you also pay for:

  • Employer National Insurance
  • A workplace pension contribution under auto-enrolment
  • Paid holiday, which is 5.6 weeks a year for a full-time employee
  • Statutory sick pay and other statutory payments when they apply
  • Recruitment costs, if you use a recruiter
  • A desk, a laptop, software licences and a phone

None of that is a reason not to hire. It's the sum worth doing first, because the advert figure and the true cost can sit a good way apart.

The fair comparison is cost against the work you actually have. If you have a full-time job's worth of PA work, a full-time salary buys a full-time person and may well be good value. If you have a couple of hours' worth a day, you'd be paying for a whole working week to get them.

Who covers when someone is off?

With an in-house PA, cover is one person wide. When they're on holiday you're back to running your own diary, and you find out how much of your week was living in their head. Flu is worse, because flu doesn't book ahead and has a gift for turning up the week of the big client meeting. If they resign, you get their notice period and then you start again from the advert.

A lone freelance VA has the same problem, only further away.

An agency should do better, and this is where a team earns its fee. We have offices in Blackheath and Lilongwe, which gives natural cover across UK and Malawi working hours. Malawi is one or two hours ahead of the UK depending on the time of year, so Lilongwe's day gets going while London is still looking for its keys. I've written more about how the two offices stretch the working day.

How much control do you give up?

Less than you'd expect, but it's a different kind of control.

With an in-house PA you can lean round a door and ask. That's a genuine advantage and no software has yet replaced it, though several have sent me a notification about it. You see how they work, they pick up how you like things, and they get to know the people who matter to you.

With a remote assistant, control moves out of the room and into the instructions. You decide what comes straight to you, what can be answered on your behalf and what gets filed. Say your three biggest customers always reach you directly, supplier invoices go into a folder for month end, and meeting requests are answered from rules you wrote down. You can check any of that whenever you like, and you have a written record of what you asked for, which is more than can be said for things said round a door. That's the sort of thing the onboarding week is for. If your inbox is the sticking point, here's how to hand it over without losing your grip.

Two more things to weigh. The first is people. An in-house employee is yours to manage, including the awkward parts, and employment law applies. With an agency, if the fit is wrong, you raise it with the agency.

The second is data. Your assistant will see personal data in your inbox, and you stay responsible for it under UK GDPR whoever is reading it. Ask any provider how they handle that, particularly for work done outside the UK. Our assistants are background-checked and trained, and you should still ask.

How do they compare side by side?

| Virtual assistant (agency) | In-house PA

Cost | Monthly fee, £1,000 with us | Salary plus employer costs

Cover | A team behind your assistant | One person, unless you hire a second

Where they work | Remotely | In your office

Day-to-day control | Agreed rules and instructions | Direct, in person

Getting started | Discovery call, matching, onboarding week | Advert, interviews, notice period

When is an in-house PA the better choice?

When the job has a physical shape. If someone needs to greet visitors, deal with the post, look after an office or sit in the room taking notes, a remote assistant can't do it, however well organised. A shared inbox has never yet made anyone a cup of tea, and I'd be uneasy if it started.

It also makes sense when you have work that fills the week, every week, or when the role depends on someone absorbing the place by being in it. If that's your business, hire the PA. We'd rather say so than sell you something that doesn't fit.

When does it make sense to outsource your PA work?

When inbox, diary and admin are eating your day but wouldn't fill someone else's week. That describes a lot of founders, consultants and busy families: too much for you, not enough for a full-time salary. It also suits anyone without an office to put a PA in, since the question of the desk goes away.

Starting is simple. A discovery call, assistant matching, an onboarding week, and then the work begins. There's no advert to write and no interview panel to assemble. If the admin turns out to spread further than the inbox, we also handle financial admin, IT helpdesk and social media, so you don't need to go looking for a second supplier.

Quick answers

Is a virtual assistant cheaper than an in-house PA?

Usually, for anything short of full-time work. Ours is £1,000 per month with no setup fees, while an in-house PA means a salary plus employer costs.

Can a remote PA do everything an in-house PA does?

Nearly everything that happens on a screen or a phone: inbox, diary, travel, research, documents and call handling. Anything that needs a person in the building needs an in-house hire.

Do I employ a virtual assistant myself?

Not if you use an agency. You pay for a service, so the employer duties of an in-house hire don't land on you.

How do I get started?

Book a discovery call, we match you with an assistant, you do an onboarding week, and then the work begins.

If you're still weighing it up, book a free discovery call and we'll go through your week with you.

virtual assistant vs PAremote PA vs in-houseoutsource PApersonal assistantshiring supportdelegation